We‘ve Seen New york city’s White Flight Prior to – The Atlantic

26August 2020

Simply south of downtown Brooklyn, right beyond the brownstones of Boerum Hill, are the Gowanus Houses: a foliage-covered public-housing complex, house to latino and primarily black households. Like the majority of citizens in New york city City, primarily everyone here has remained in the middle of the pandemic, and a good few said they would not have it any other way.

“Why would I go anywhere? This is house; I was born around here, been here permanently,” Jaime Gonzalez, a 51-year-old man who lives near the houses, informed me, as we stood next to a store throughout the street from the complex. Gonzalez, who asked only half-jokingly if I was an undercover police officer before agreeing to speak with me, doesn’t care much for the news media. So he had not heard about the Really Online backlash to reports of the city’s fleeing rich and, particularly, to the New York City Post essay entitled “New York City City Is Dead Forever.”

After I described the essence of that piece, which numerous have called elitist, he shrugged his broad shoulders, shrouded in a big light-blue polo. “That’s just talk,” Gonzalez said. “People just like to hear themselves talk.” Leaping, unprompted, into the class politics of the debate, he added, “Even if you have a master’s degree in English, or something else, that doesn’t indicate you understand whatever.”

Gonzalez’s surroundings, vibrant as ever, lent reliability to his dismissiveness: One of his pals was having fun with her dog and bantering with a young woman as they nodded to bachata blasting in the background– a Brooklyn scene typical of any August. Another buddy, whose work shifts have been minimized to three days a week due to the fact that of the pandemic, hung neighboring talking on the phone, delicately rubbing the pet python draped around his neck. As Gonzalez talked with me– about his ridicule for the snake and for increased lease, and about how his senior mom endured the coronavirus and contracted– he stopped briefly to say hey there in Spanish or English to anyone he knew going by, which at one point felt like every fourth man, lady, or kid.

More Stories

That social heat is just one ray of the city’s ongoing vibrance, especially in its majority Brown and black districts, which were disproportionately affected by the infection. The stubborn buoyancy of the city this summer– even if silenced by uncertainty, mask using, and social distancing– doesn’t mesh with the desperate-sounding accounts presented by some cable-news programs and traditional news outlets. And it definitely isn’t reflective of the apocalyptic representations used by some conservatives, such as the 73-year-old star James Woods, a popular fan of President Donald Trump. Woods, whose videotaped drive through a barren, boarded-up stretch of Midtown went viral in mid-August, described the city as the “once magnificent New york city under Democrat rule.”

A scene from Red Hook, Brooklyn, in July (Andrew Burton/ Getty)

It holds true that rental jobs in New york city City are at historic highs, that some streets are strangely sporadic when juxtaposed with their pre-coronavirus “City that never ever sleeps” personality. And the city’s unemployment rate, which stands at about 20 percent, according to the state labor department’s newest computation, is an awful fact, especially considering that Congress let the federal unemployment supplement expire in July. Yet it’s likewise true that New Yorkers– the majority of whom do not live in the most affluent passages of Manhattan– do not appear especially hurt about, or fascinated by, the viewed loss of Manhattan as a play ground for the abundant.

The consulting and financing bros of the Town, Murray Hill, and the Lower East Side may be stuck at their household house in North Jersey or Connecticut (if they’re more youthful), or lodged in some Instagrammable enclave (if they’re older). But the Rockaways, on the southern edge of Queens, 16 train stops from the edge of Manhattan, have been whizzing on any provided weekend with an inviting middle-class assortment of energy. If you walk, as I did, to the beach there, and (in accordance with New york city guidelines) remove your mask, nap in the hot sand, and splash into the cool sea, then it can nearly feel as if there is no pandemic. The Atlantic Ocean water rushing in between your toes because minute is no various from the Atlantic Ocean waves brushing up versus the wealthy shores of Fire Island or the Hamptons.


The “Why I’m Leaving New york city” essay category began in the 1960s with Joan Didion’s “Goodbye to All That,” an elegy about her leaving Manhattan behind because, as she composed, “at some point the golden rhythm was broken, and I am not that young any longer.” The category was given life once again in the late 2000s and 2010s, largely by the city’s blogging imaginative class, as the pay cuts and layoffs of the economic crisis lingered and the cost of living skyrocketed. During the coronavirus pandemic, a brand-new version of this essay has developed, slanted towards health concerns, however nevertheless imbued with class benefit– which, in American cities, constantly converges with race. The New Yorker columnist Masha Gessen considers this crossway with their own entry into the “why I’m leaving” category, writing: “‘Do we want to be those people?’ my child, Yolka, asked. She suggested, Do we want to be the abundant white people who leave the besieged city due to the fact that they can? ‘Yes,’ I said.”

New york city was plagued by cycles of inequality long before it was plagued by COVID-19. “Rich white people may be leaving cities for the suburbs, just as they did years ago,” Eric Klinenberg, a sociology professor at New york city University, informed me. “And the dreadful thing for Brown and black city neighborhoods is that they suffer either way.” When white households left cities in the ’60s through the ’80s, debilitating divestment followed. A “renewed hunger for city features” brought cities back to life, Klinenberg said, however that growth was racially exclusionary, as anyone who has read about gentrification or been on the wrong side of its effects understands. “We’re all seeing something comparable play out now,” he said, with the caution that it is too soon to understand whether the present outflows are “momentary” or “long lasting” relocations.

Regardless of the result, pre-pandemic New york city is as most likely to come back as Sex and the City New york city– or the Do the Right Thing, Taxi Driver, or Mad Men New Yorks before it. More than 19,000 people here have had their life cut short by the coronavirus, and a 3rd of the city’s businesses may close. In the crannies of every borough, a number of memory-filled neighborhood staples are currently gone. But New york city isn’t dead– it’s as essential as ever, just altering, for a while or permanently, like constantly. Perpetual shift is the only rhythm this city understands.

In his wrenching post-9/ 11 essay, “The Way We Live Now: 11-11-01; Lost and Found,” Colson Whitehead composed, “No matter how long you have been here, you are a New Yorker the very first time you say, ‘That utilized to be Munsey’s’ or ‘That utilized to be the Tic Toc Lounge.'” He argues, “You are a New Yorker when what existed before is more solid and real than what is here now.” The city feels indeterminate this summer, however that has only increased the appreciation of the constants that stay. The large playground at the Marcy Houses in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, is still house to an interplay of children’s laughter and 20-somethings’ music. In Liberty Park, Queens– where my barber, at last, can provide me a haircut– the old blue-collar white people still nod to passersby as they trim their front lawn. At Brooklyn Bridge Park, I saw how delighted hour has moved outdoors, and I eavesdropped on picnic rendezvous in between young couples and circles of pals. In Central Harlem, ’80s and ’90s R&B still thumps from the late afternoon to the late evening, vibrating in your chest.

The cold will come, the outdoor recreation will end, and the infection will not be gone. What kind of life arrives after that, nobody understands. In the meantime, citizens stick around outside for a while longer at dusk, absorbing as much of summer as possible. Inhaling what still seems like their city, as though they can make it through this winter if they take in enough of what’s left.Source: theatlantic.com

Our Score
Click to rate this post!
[Total: 0 Average: 0]

Upgrade Your Listing

Add images, video, and more details to your listing! More information means more clicks. More clicks means more quotes!

Free listing includes: business name, address, phone, website, google map

Upgraded listing includes: business name, address, phone, website, EMAIL ADDRESS, COMPANY LOGO, VIDEO, IMAGE SLIDE SHOW, FEATURED LISTING PLACEMENT